With the S&P 500 delivering impressive returns for two years in a row, many are wondering: could the market be heading toward a downturn in 2025? After a total return of 26.3% in 2023, including dividends, the index is up around 29% in 2024. Such growth has raised concerns about whether the market might be overvalued.
The SPX500, which tracks the performance of the S&P 500, has become a focal point for analysts debating whether the rally is sustainable. Even prominent investors are making cautious moves, with Warren Buffett selling some of his holdings and building cash reserves.
Let’s explore two key questions that could determine if a market crash is on the horizon: Are stocks overpriced? And how will artificial intelligence (AI) impact the market?
Are Stock Valuations Too High?
By historical standards, the S&P 500 trades at levels that have previously signaled corrections. One popular measure is the Shiller price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, which smooths out earnings over ten years and adjusts for inflation. As of December 2024, this ratio stands at 38.8—levels seen only twice before: during the dot-com bubble of the late 1990s and in early 2022. In both cases, significant market pullbacks followed.
Does this mean a crash is imminent? Not necessarily. The Shiller P/E ratio looks at past data, but markets often focus on the future. For instance, tech companies driving today’s market growth, such as Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia, are delivering strong earnings growth, which helps bring down future P/E estimates. Nvidia, for example, has a current P/E ratio of 56, but analysts predict it will drop to 32 based on its projected earnings for next year.
However, the market’s heavy reliance on a few dominant companies is worth noting. Apple, Microsoft, and Nvidia alone make up nearly 20% of the S&P 500, making the index vulnerable to any shifts in their performance. Could this concentration create risks for the broader market? If growth for these key players slows, it could weigh heavily on the overall index.
Will Artificial Intelligence Drive Markets Higher or Cause a Crash?
How significant is artificial intelligence in shaping the market’s future? AI is one of the biggest growth drivers in the tech sector, with major companies heavily investing in its development. However, as with the dot-com bubble of the 1990s, excessive reliance on one technology can pose risks.
During the dot-com era, many internet companies collapsed due to unsustainable business models. Is today’s AI boom different? Unlike the dot-com era, which startups drove, the current AI wave is led by large, profitable corporations with diversified operations. Tech giants like Nvidia, Amazon, and Microsoft are racing to advance AI technologies, especially in cloud computing and infrastructure.
But could this spending dry up? If AI infrastructure investment suddenly slows—similar to what happened to Cisco during the early 2000s—it could lead to market turbulence. On the other hand, as long as companies continue to see returns on their AI investments, this trend may support further market growth.
For example, Amazon, Microsoft, and Alphabet’s cloud-computing divisions are already showing revenue growth fueled by AI. Additionally, software companies are beginning to adopt AI-driven tools to improve efficiency and cut costs. These solutions could encourage further AI-related spending across industries if they deliver measurable benefits. However, this success is far from guaranteed and depends on whether businesses outside the tech sector see value from AI in their operations.
What Could 2025 Hold for the Market?
The stock market’s future in 2025 largely depends on valuations and the performance of AI-related investments. Historical data suggests caution, with high valuations often leading to corrections. However, strong earnings growth and AI’s transformative potential could keep the market moving upward—at least for now.
It’s also important to consider the broader timeline of bull markets. On average, these periods last about 5 ½ years, and the current one is just over two years old. Does this mean there’s still room for growth? Possibly, but unexpected shifts in corporate earnings or investment trends could change the picture quickly.
In the end, understanding the role of key factors like valuations and AI spending can help market participants weather uncertainty. While no one can predict the future, staying informed about these trends can provide valuable insights into what might lie ahead for the stock market.
Also read interesting articles at Disboard.co.uk
